Directive 85/374 – European Victory or a Defective Product Itself?
AbstractOver the last few decades, product liability has become a well-established area of European private law. It surfaced as a subject in its own right in the US in 1963 in the judgment of Greenman v Yuba Power Products. In contrast, modern European product liability originated over two decades later when Directive 85/374 was introduced in 1985, concerning liability for defective products (Product Liability Directive hereafter), and embracing the idea of strict liability of manufacturers for damage caused by circulating a defective product. The Directive aims for full harmonisation and the provision of a high and equal level of consumer protection. In recent years the EU Product Liability Directive has become something of a global smash hit, providing not only a template for EU Member States, but also an international blueprint used by countries worldwide, including South Africa, Australia, Brazil and countries in the Asia Pacific Region when reforming their product liability regimes. There is no doubt that the Directive politically speaking has been a major success, representing arguably the most powerful example of European harmonisation efforts within the area of tort law where previous initiatives have failed,3 and influencing the law worldwide. However its actual impact has been negligible; The Directive has not done much to unify EU product liability law in action, nor strengthened consumer protection. In the majority of countries the implementation of the Directive has not significantly affected the nature or frequency of product liability litigation. If victims sue at all they rarely make use of the special legislation implementing the Directive’s strict liability rules.
European Commission; More Protection for Consumers against defective products proposed. Commission Information Memo P-72/76, September 1976 [EU Commission – Press Notice] COM (76) 372 final.
Commission; Second Report from the Commission on the Application of Directive 85/374 on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States concerning liability for defective products. COM (2000) 893 final.
Commission; Third Report on the application of Council Directive on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States concerning liability for defective products. COM (2006) 496 final.
European Commission; Fourth report on the application of Council Directive on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States concerning liability for defective products. (COM (2011) 547 final).
Economic and Social Committee (ECOSOC); Report on the Proposal for a Council Directive on Liability for defective products. COM (1976) 372 final.
Economic and Social Committee (ECOSOC); Opinion on the proposal for a Council Directive relating to the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States concerning liability for defective products. OJ C114/05 (1979).
Report of the Legal Affairs Committee [1979-1980] European Parliament Document COM No.71.
Andenas, Bell, Fairgrieve; The Emergence of a Common European Law in the Area of Tort law: the EU Contribution. Published in W. van Gerven; Comparative Law in a regionally integrated Europe. In Comparative Law in the 21st century WG Hart Legal Workshop Series, London: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2002, 155 Chapter 6.
John S. Allee; Product Liability. ALM Properties, Inc., Law Journal Press, 1984 available via Google books http://books.google.de/books?id=Kc4BlWh_BoC&pg=PR2&dq=John+S.+Allee;+Product+ Liability.+ALM+Properties,+Inc.,+Law+Journal+Press,+1984&hl=de&sa=X&ei=ByHjUf6e KMOswb4i4G4DA&ved=0CDEQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=John%20S.%20Allee%3B%20 Product%20Liability.%20ALM%20Properties%2C%20Inc.%2C%20Law%20Journal%20 Press%2C%201984&f=false
H. Bartl; Produkthaftung nach neuem EG-Recht: ProdHaftG. Kommentar zum deutschen Produkthaftungsgesetz. Verlag Moderne Industrie, 1989.
Lothar W. Baum; Forum Shopping in Product Liability Actions: A Comparison Between the United States, France and Germany. [Thesis] University of Georgia School of Law, 1988.
Anita Bernstein; Looking at Europe for the Difference Between Strict and Fault-Based Liability. Journal of Products Liability Volume 14. 207, 1992.
Nicolo Cornelius Bianco; Modern Trends in Product liability. [Dissertation] University of South Africa, 2002.
William Boger; The Harmonisation of European Products Liability Law. Fordham International Journal Vol.7 Issue 1 Article 1, 1984.
Edita Brozaityte; How is the shift from minimum to maximum harmonisation reflected in the Proposal for the Directive on Consumer Rights and is it Legally feasible and desirable? [Master Thesis] Tilburg University, 2009-2010.
Richard M. Buxbaum, G. Hertig, A. Hirsch & K.J. Hopt (eds.); European Economic and Business law: Legal and Economic Analysis on Integration and Harmonisation. De Gruyter & Co., 1996.
Alberto Cavaliere; The Economic Impact of Product Liability and Product Safety Regulations in the European Union. Quaderni del Dipartimento di Economia Pubblica E Territoriale – Università di Pavia n.4/2001, 2001.
Marianne Corr; Problems with the EC Approach to Harmonisation of Product Liability Law. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law, Spring/Summer 90, Vol.22 Issue 2/3, pp. 235-244, 1990.
Thomas Eger & Hans-Bernd Schäfer; Research Handbook on the Economics of European Union Law. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, 2012 available via Google books http:// books.google.de/books?id=sKSS0bMSih4C&printsec=frontcover&dq=Thomas+Eger+%26+ HansBernd+Schäfer;+Research+Handbook+on+the+Economics+of+European+Union+Law+Edward+Elgar+Publishing+Limited,+2012&hl=de&sa=X&ei=TZXjUcy_Gc3EtAadioCIAQ&v ed=0CDEQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=externalities&f=false
Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press 2005.
Duncan Fairgrieve; L’exception française? The French law of product liability. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product liability in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Duncan Fairgrieve & Geraint Howells; Rethinking Product Liability: A Missing Element in the European Commission’s Third Review of the European Product Liability Directive (Legislation and Reports). The Modern Law Review Limited Journal Compilation, pp.962-978, 2007.
Duncan Fairgrieve & Geraint Howells; State of art of European Product Liability. Published in Australian Product Liability Reporter Vol.18 Issue 2, 2007.
Michael G. Faure; Product Liability and Product Safety in Europe: Harmonisation or Differentiation? Kyklos: International Review for Social Sciences Vol.5 pp.467-508, 2000.
Michael G. Faure; How Law and Economics may contribute to the Harmonisation of Tort Law in Europe. Published in R. Zimmerman (Ed.); Grunstrukturen des Europäischen Deliktsrechts pp.31-82, Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2003.
Mark L Flear, Anne-Maree Farrell, Tamara K. Hervey & Thérèse Murphy; European Law and Health Technologies. Oxford University Press, 2013.
Ralph H. Folsom & Ralph B. Lake & Ved P. Nanda; European Union Law After Maastricht: A Practical Guide for Lawyers Outside the Common Market. Kluwer Law international, 1996.
Thomas V. Greer; Product Liability in the European Community: The Legislative History. Journal of Consumer Affairs Vol.26 Issue 1, 1992.
Arthur S. Hartkamp & Ewoud Herman Hondius; Towards a European Civil Code 3rd edition. Kluwer Law International, 2004.
G. Hoftstede; Cultures Consequences 2nd edition. London, Sage, 2001.
Geraint Howells; Product Liability – A History of Harmonisation. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability in Comparative Prospective. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Geraint Howells; Defect in English Law: Lessons for harmonisation of European Product Liability. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press pp.138-152, 2005.
Geraint G. Howells; The Rise of European Consumer Law – Whither National Consumer Law? Sydney Law Review Vol.28 Issue 63, 2006.
Geraint Howells; Is European Product Liability Harmonized? Tort and Insurance Law Vol.23, 2008.
Peter W. Huber & Robert E. Litan; The Liability Maze: The Impact of Liability Law on Safety and Innovation. Brookings Institution, Washington, 1991.
Rod Hunter & Lucas Bergkamp Hunton & Williams; Should Europe’s Liability Regime Be Expended? Comments on the European Commission’s Green Paper on Product Liability.
Product Safety & Liability Reporter Vol.29, No.17 pp.403-417, 2001 Bureau of National Affairs. Inc., Washington, D.C.
R. Hulsenbek & D. Campbell; Product Liability: Prevention, Practice and Process in Europe and the United States. Kluwer Law International, 1989.
Christian Joerges; The Challenges of Europeanization in the Realm of Private Law: A Plea for a New Legal Discipline. EUI Working Paper LAW No.2004/12 European University Institute, Florence Department of Law 2004.
X.E. Kramer & C.H. van Rhee; Civil Litigation in a Globalizing World. Asser Press, 2012.
Bernhard A. Koch; Damage Caused by Genetically Modified Organisms: Comparative Survey of Redress options for Harm to Persons, Property or the Environment. De Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin 2010. Available via Goggle books http://books.google.de/book s?id=YXML8FZdYv8C&pg=PA185&dq=J.+Calais+Auloy;+‘Menace+européenne&hl=de&sa =X&ei=TYPjUbiUC4eIOOGCgbAO&ved=0CDgQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=J.%20Calais%- 20Auloy%3B%20‘Menace%20européenne&f=false
Rebecca Korzec; Dashing Consumer Hopes: Strict Products Liability and the Demise of the Consumer Expectations Test. Boston College International & Comparative Law Review Vol. XX, No.2, 1997.
Pierre Larouche; ‘Legally Relevant Damage’ and a priori limits to non-contractual liability in the DCFR. [TILEC Discussion Paper] December 2008 (DP 2008-045).
Pierre Legrand; The impossibility of Legal transplants. Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law Vol.4 1997.
Stefan Lenze; German Product Liability Law; Between European Directives, American Restatements and common sense. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Lori M. Linger; The Products Liability Directive: A Mandatory Development Risks Defense. Fordham International Law Journal Volume 14 Issue 2 Art.6 pp.478-509, 1990-1991.
Marco B.M. Loos; The Influence of European consumer law on general contract law and the need for spontaneous harmonisation: On the disturbance and reconstruction of the coherence of national contract law and consumer law under the influence of European law. Centre for the Study of European Contract Law Working Paper Series No.2006/02, 2006 p.8
Lovell; Product Liability in the European Union: A report for the European Commission (European Commission Study). February 2003 Markt/2001/11/D.
Vanessa Mak; The Degree of Harmonisation in the Proposed Consumer Rights Directive: A Review in the Light of Liability for Products. Tilburg Institute of Comparative and Transnational Law (TICOM) Working Paper No. 2009/03, published in Geraint Howells and Reiner Schulze (eds.); Modernizing and Harmonizing Consumer Contract Law. Sellier, München March pp.307-24, 2009.
Alfred E. Mottur; The European Product Liability Directive: A Comparison with U.S. Law. An Analysis of its Impact on Trade and a Recommendation for Reform so as to accomplish harmonisation and consumer protection. Law & Policy in International Business Vol.25, 1993-1994.
Kathleen M. Nilles; Defining the Limits of Liability: A Legal and Political Analysis of the European Community Products Liability Directive. Virginia Journal of International Law Vol.25, 1985.
Frank A. Orban, III; Product liability: A Comparative Legal Restatement – Foreign National Law astatine the EEC Directive. Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law Vol.8 Issue 2 pp.342-408, 1978.
Nebbia Paolisa; Internal market and the harmonisation of European Contract law. Published in Tridimas Takis; Nebbia Paolisa; European Union Law for the twenty-first century: rethinking the new legal order (Vol. 2 International market and free movement community policies). Oxford University Press, 2004.
Eleonora Rajneri; Interaction Between the European Directive on Product Liability and the former liability regime in Italy. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability In Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Matthias Reimann; Product Liability in a Global Context: the Hollow Victory of the European Model. European Review of Private Law 2-2003 [128-154] Kluwer International 2003.
Christoph U. Schmid; Co-ordination problems between European and national private law: a Scenario to be avoided in the Europeanization of Tenancy Law. [Background Paper] European Private Law Forum EUI Florence, 2003 available via http://www.iue.it
Reiner Schulze (eds.); Compensation of Private Losses: The Evolution of Torts in European Business Law. Sellier European Law Publisher GmbH, 2011.
Niamh Nic Shuibhne; Regulating the Internal Market. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, 2006.
Jan M. Smits; European Private Law: A Plea for a Spontaneous Legal Order. Maastricht Working Papers, Faculty of Law, 2006.
Jan M. Smits: Mixed Jurisdictions: Lessons for European Harmonisation? Electronic Journal of Comparative law Vol.12 Issue I, 2008.
Jane Stapleton; A Personal Evaluation of the Implementation of the EEC Directive (85/374/EEC) on Products Liability. 1 Torts Law Journal 90 (1993).
Jane Stapleton; Product Liability. Butterworth Legal Publishers, 1994.
Jane Stapleton; Product Liability in the United Kingdom: The Myths of Reform. Texas International Law Journal Vol.34, 1999.
Jane Stapleton; Bugs in Angelo-American Products Liability. South Carolina Law Review Vol.53 Issue 1225 pp.1226-1259, 2001-2002.
Simon Taylor; Harmonisation or Divergence? A comparison of French and English product liability rules. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Patrick Thieffry; Strict Product Liability in the EEC: Implementation, Practice and Impact on U.S. Manufacturers of Directive 85/374. Tort & Institutions Law Journal Volume 25, 1989.
Cees van Dam, Dutch Case Law on the EU Product Liability Directive. Published in Duncan Fairgrieve; Product Liability in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Cees van Dam; European Tort Law. Oxford University Press, 2006.
Cees van Dam; European Tort Law and the Many Cultures of Europe. Published in Thomas Whilhelmsson (ed.); Private Law and the Cultures of Europe. Chapter 4 pp.53-76 Kluwer Law International BV, 2007.
Roger Van den Bergh; Subsidiarity as an Economic Demarcation Principle and the Emergence of European Private Law. Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law Vol.5 pp.129-152, 1998.
Roger Van den Berg; Economics in a legal straightjacket: the difficult reception of economic analysis in European Law. Paper Presented at the Workshop Empirical Research and Legal Realism. Setting the Agenda, Haifa, June 6-9 1999.
Walter van Gerven; European Court of Justice as a Means of Unification of Private Law? Published in A. Hartkamp e.a. (Eds.); Towards a European Civil Code, 3nd ed. Kluwer Law International, 2004.
Van Wassenaer & A.J. Otto Van Catwijk; Productaansprakelijkheid in Serie Praktijkhandleidingen. Zwolle: Tjeenl Willink, 1986.
Kiliaan van Wees and Karel Brookhuis; Product liability for ADAS; Legal and Human factors perspectives. Delft University of technology, Policy and Management, EJTIR, Vol.5, no.4, pp.357-372, 2005.
Thomas Wilhelmsson (ed.); Private Law and the Cultures of Europe. Kluwer Law International, 2007.
Shanti Williamson; Compensation for Infected Blood Products: A and others v National Blood Authority and Another. Electronic Journal of Comparative Law Vol.7 Issue 5, ISSN 1205-8629, 2003.
British Institute of International and Comparative Law. http://www.biicl.org/plf/
European Council Presidency Conclusions, 23-24 March, 2000. http://www.ec.europa.eu/index_en.htm
Institute for European Tort Law (ETL). http://ectil.org/etl/Einfuhrung.aspx
Science in Society. http://scienceinsociety.northwestern.edu/content/articles/2009/research-digest/ thalidomide/title-tba