The survival of the ‘Anti-Party Party Paradox’
Evidence from the Five Stars Movement
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26481/marble.2019.v1.746Keywords:
populism, Five Stars Movement, Anti-Party Parties, Party RoutinizationAbstract
As of June 1, 2018, Italy is governed by two populist factions: the Five Stars Movement (5SM) and the League. The former, being an anti-party party, has become the first political force in only nine years of existence by advocating for a desired change of Italian politics. The latter is instead an extreme-right wing populist faction that has previously ruled with Berlusconi’s Forza Italia party and was heavily involved in corruption scandals. At first sight, this governmental coalition seems antithetical with the proclaimed purity and difference of the 5SM from its ordinary political competitors. What is more, not only the 5SM has recently adopted internal rules which resemble those of established parties, but it has also performed behaviours which are in sharp contradiction with its ideology and values. In light of this contrast, this paper extends Cas Mudde’s (1996) anti-party party paradox to the 5SM by examining how anti-party parties behave in power with other populist factions. It adopts party routinisation theory to analyse how changes of internal organisation within the movement have effectively translated into external behaviours which are ‘party-like’. What emerges is that the Five Stars Movement, despite governing with another populist faction, has become internally and externally routinised as a normal party in the necessary limitations of the Italian political reality. As such, the anti-party party paradox survives even when compromise is achieved at the national level with another populist party.
References
Arter, D., & Kestilä-Kekkonen, E. (2014). Measuring the Extent of Party Institutionalisation: a Populist Entrepreneur Party. West European Politics, 37(5), 932-965.
Bardi, L. (1996). Anti-party sentiment and party system change in Italy. European Journal of Political Research, 29(3), 345-363.
Barr, R. R. (2009). Populists, outsiders and anti-establishment politics. Party Politics, 15(1), 29-48.
Becchi, P. (2015). Movimento 5 Stelle. Fine di un sogno. Mondoperaio N. 09/2015. Retrieved from: https://paolobecchi.wordpress.com/2015/09/01/fine-di-un-sogno/
Berlusconi: “No alla fiducia e centrodestra unito al voto”. Ma Salvini: “Alleanza con Fi? Ci penserò”. (2018). La Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://www.repubblica.it/politica/2018/05/28/news/salvini_se_berlusconi_lo_vota_a dio_alleanza_-197549039/
Bielasiak, J. (2001). On the Institutionalization of Party Regimes in Emerging Democracies. Working Paper no. 351. Glasgow: University of Strathclyde.
Biorcio, R., & Sampugnaro, R. (2019). Introduction: The Five-Star Movement from the street local and national institutions. Contemporary Italian Politics, 1-10.
Bordignon, F., & Ceccarini, L. (2014). Protest and project, leader and party: normalisation of the Five Star Movement. Contemporary Italian Politics, 1-19.
Canovan, M. (1999). Trust the People! Populism and the Two Faces of Democracy. Political Studies, XLVII, 2-16.
Casal Bértoa, F. (2016). The Three Waves of Party System Institutionalization Studies: A Multi- or Uni-Dimensional Concept?. Political Studies Review, 16(1), 60-72.
Caso Diciotti, il film dei dieci giorni in mare. (2019). La Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2019/01/24/news/la_scheda_ _caso_diciotti_il_film_dei_dieci_giorni_in_mare-217364190/
Caso Diciotti, il suicidio dei 5 stelle è un requiem per la democrazia. (2019). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2019/02/19/caso-diciotti il-suicidio-dei-5-stelle-e-un-requiem-per-la-democrazia/4982230/
Caso Diciotti: M5s dice no al processo a Salvini, ma la base grillina si spacca. Il vicepremier: “Ringrazio Di Maio”. (2019). La Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://www.repubblica.it/politica/2019/02/18/news/caso_diciotti_i_grillini_dicono_n _al_processo_per_salvini-219493494/
Castells, M. (2012). Networks of Outrage and Hope: Social Movements in the Internet Age. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
Ceccarini, L., & Bordignon, F. (2016). The five stars continue to shine: the consolidation of Grillo’s movement party’ in Italy. Contemporary Italian Politics, 8(2), 131-159.
Ceccarini, L., & Bordignon, F. (2018). Towards the 5 star party. Contemporary Italian
Politics, 10(4), 346-362.
Comunitàzione. (2019). Retrieved from: http://www.comunitazione.it/leggi.asp?id_art=2506&id_area=168
Cuzzocrea, A. (2018). Contratto di governo M5s-Lega, la bozza del 15 maggio: dallo stop alla Tav ai centri per migranti da espellere. La Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://www.repubblica.it/politica/2018/05/16/news/m5s_lega_bozza_contratto_15_m aggio_18-196576957/
Daalder, H. (2002). Parties: Denied, Dismissed, or Redundant? A Critique. In Gunther, R.,
Montero, J. R., & Linz, J. J. (Eds.), Political Parties: Old Concepts and New Challenges (pp. 39-57). Oxford University Press.
De Petris, A. (2015). Programs, Strategies and Electoral Campaigns of the Five Stars Movement I Italy. A brand new Party Model or an “Anti-Party” State of Mind?. In De Petris, A., & Poguntke, T. (Eds.), Anti-Party Parties in Germany and Italy: Protest Movements and Parliamentary Democracy (pp. 125-148). Roma: Luiss University Press.
De Petris, A., & Poguntke, T. (2015). Anti-Party Parties in Germany and Italy: Protest Movements and Parliamentary Democracy. Roma: Luiss University Press.
Diciotti, il Senato vota no all’autorizzazione a procedere contro Salvini. Che in aula ringrazia il M5S: “Le cose si fanno in due”. (2019). La Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://www.repubblica.it/politica/2019/03/20/news/salvini_voto_diciotti_senato 222049852/
Electoral Geography. (2015). Retrieved from: https://www.electoralgeography.com/new/en/countries/p/poland/poland-legislative election-2015.html
Electoral Geography. (2018a). Retrieved from: https://www.electoralgeography.com/new/en/countries/i/italy/italy-legislative election-2018.html
Electoral Geography. (2018b). Retrieved from: https://www.electoralgeography.com/new/en/countries/h/hungary/hungary-legislative election-2018.html
Flanagan, S. C., & Dalton, R. J. (1984). Parties Under Stress: Realignment and Dealignment in Advanced Industrial Societies. Wester European Politics, 7, 7-23.
Fondi della Lega, “Vaffanbagno”: quando i leghisti progettavano di far sparire i soldi. (2018). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/in- edicola/articoli/2018/09/08/vaffanbagno-quando-i-leghisti-progettavano-di-far-sparire i-soldi/4611985/
Fondi Lega, cosa dice la legge e perchè è stata decisa la confisca. I pm di Genova a caccia del tesoro (che forse non c’è). (2018). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/07/12/fondi-lega-cosa-dice-la-legge-e-perche-e stata-decisa-la-confisca-i-pm-di-genova-a-caccia-del-tesoro-che-forse-non ce/4483874/
Fondi Lega, la Cassazione conferma sequestro 49 milioni di euro. Carroccio: “Ora ricorso a Corte diritti Ue”. (2018). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/11/10/fondi-lega-la-cassazione-conferma sequestro-49-milioni-di-euro-carroccio-ora-ricorso-a-corte-diritti-ue/4755283/
Gidengil, E., Blais, A., Nevitte, N., & Nadeau, R. (2001) The correlates and consequences of anti-partysism in the 1997 Canadian election. Party Politics, 7(4), 491-513.
Giostra, A. (2018). Il “Partito” del Fatto Quotidiano. Chi trova un nemico trova un tesoro. Trieste: Asterios Editore.
Governo, Di Maio a Salvini: “Noi mai con Berlusconi. La Lega nega voto per guai finanziari”. Lui risponde: “Sono insulti”. Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/05/03/governo-di-maio-salvini-noi-mai-con berlusconi-la-lega-nega-voto-per-guai-finanziari-lui-non-replico-insulti/4328354/
Governo, quando Di Maio diceva: “Noi 5SM mai con i partiti estremisti” (2018). L’Espresso: la Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://video.repubblica.it/politica/governo-quando-di maio-diceva--noi-m5smai-con-i-partiti-estremisti/306419/307049
Harmel, R., Svasand, L., & Mjelde, H. (2016). Party Institutionalization and De institutionalization: Concepts and Indicators. Political Organizations, ECPR joint sessions of Workshops, Pisa, April 2016.
Immerfall, S. (1993). German party sociology in the nineties. On the state of a discipline of turmoil. European Journal of Political Research, 23, 465-482.
Italian Constitution. (1946). Retrieved from: https://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costituzione_inglese.pdf
Kenneth, J., & Gillies, R. (1980). Continuity and Change. In Kenneth, J. Political Parties: A Cross-National Analysis (pp. 162-170). New York: Free Press.
Jepperson, R. (1991). Institutions, Institutional Effects, and Institutionalism. In Powell, W. W., & Dimaggio, P. J. (Eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis (pp. 143-163). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kitschelt, H. (2005). Movement Parties. In Katz, R. S., & Crotty, W., Handbook of Party Politics (pp. 278-290). London: Sage Publications.
Levitsky, S. (1998). Institutionalization and Peronism. The Concept, the Case and the Case for Unpacking the Concept. Party Politics, 4(1), 77-92.
M5s, Di Maio: “Faremo convergenze programmatiche e non alleanze. Pronti 20 punti per l’Italia con chi ci sta. (2018). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/01/21/m5s-di-maio-faremo-convergenze programmatiche-e-non-alleanze-pronti-20-punti/4105923/
M5s, Toninelli: “Salvini? Ha svenduto la democrazia. E’ indegno e il Movimento non si allea con gli indegni”. (2017). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2017/10/30/m5s-toninelli-salvini-ha-svenduto-la democrazia-e-indegno-e-il-movimento-non-si-allea-con-gli-indegni/3946004/
Mainwaring, S., & Scully, T. (1995). Building Democratic Institutions: Party Systems in Latin America. Stanford University Press.
Mainwaring, S., & Torcal, M. (2005). Party System Institutionalization and Party System Theory After the Third Wave of Democratization. In Katz, R. S., & Crotty, W. (Eds.), Handbook of Party Politics. London: Sage Publications.
Morlino, L. (1988). Democracy between Consolidation and Crisis: Parties, Groups and Citizens in Southern Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Movarelli, M. (2016). From dreams to reality: the challenges of Italy’s Five Star Movement. European View, 15, 213-221.
Mudde, C. (1996). The Paradox of the Anti-Party Party: Insights from the Extreme Right. Party Politics, 2(2), 265-276.
Müller, J. (2016). What Is Populism. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Musso, M., & Maccaferri, M. (2018). At the origins of the political discourse of the 5-Star Movement (M5S): Internet, direct democracy and the “future of the past”. Internet Histories: Digital Technology, Culture and Society, 2(1-2), 98-120.
Non-Statute. (2009). Retrieved from: https://www.politicalpartydb.org/wp content/uploads/Statutes/Italy/IT_M5S_2009.pdf
O’Donnel, G. (1996). Illusions About Consolidation. Journal of Democracy, 7, 34-51.
Palazzolo, S. (2018). Diciotti, per Salvini: “Sequestro di persona aggravato”. L’ira del ministro: “Io eletto, giudici no”. La Repubblica. Retrieved from: https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2018/09/07/news/carabinieri_notificano_atto_a_sa vini-205844828/
Panebianco, A. (1992). Political parties: organization and power. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Parlamentarie Regulation. (2018). Retrieved from: https://s3-eu-west 1.amazonaws.com/associazionerousseau/documenti/regolamento_parlamentarie2018. df
Pedahzur, A., & Brichta, A. (2002). The Institutionalization of Extreme Right-Wing Charismatic Parties: A Paradox?. Party Politics, 8(1), 31-49.
Pedersen, M. N. (1982). Towards a New Typology of Party Lifespans and Minor Parties. Scandinavian Political Studies, 5(1), 1-16.
Poguntke, T. (1996). Anti-party sentiment – Conceptual thoughts and empirical evidence: Explorations into a minefield. European Journal of Political Research, 29, 319-344.
Renzi fa il padrone del Pd: “Mai con i 5 stelle”. Di Maio: “Non riescono a liberarsi di lui. Dicono no ai temi, la pagheranno”. (2018). Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/04/29/renzi-fa-il-padrone-del-pd-mai-con-5 stelle-di-maio-non-riescono-liberarsi-di-lui-hanno-detto-no-ai-temi-la pagheranno/4324126/
Rovira Kaltwasser, C., & Taggart, P. (2016). Dealing with populists in government: a framework for analysis. Democratization, 23(2), 201-220.
Russo, L., Riera, P., & Verthé, T. (2017). Tracing the electorate of the MoVimento Cinque Stelle: an ecological inference analysis. Italian Political Science Review, 47(1), 45-62.
Scheler, M., & Frings, M. (2003). Ressentiment (New ed., Marquette studies in philosophy, 7). Milwaukee, Wis.: Marquette University Press.
Statute. (2017). Retrieved from: https://s3-eu-west 1.amazonaws.com/associazionerousseau/documenti/statuto_MoVimento_2017.pdf
Tarchi, M. (2008). Italy: A Country of Many Populisms. In Albertazzi, D., & McDonnel, D. (Eds.), Twenty-First Century Populism: The Spectre of Western European Democracy (pp. 84-99). Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.
Tizian, G., & Vergine, S. (2018a). Ecco perché la Lega deve restitutire i 49 milioni. Lo dicono i Giudici. L’Espresso: La Repubblica. Retrieved from: http://espresso.repubblica.it/attualita/2018/07/18/news/ecco-perche-la-lega-deve restituire-i-49-milioni-lo-dicono-i-giudici-1.325015?refresh_ce
Tizian, G., & Vergine, S. (2018b). Così la Lega ha fatto sparire 49 millioni di euro. L’Espresso: La Repubblica. Retrieved from: http://espresso.repubblica.it/inchieste/2018/12/18/news/lega-49-milioni-spariti 1.329766?refresh_ce
Torcal, M., Gunther, R., & Montero, J. R. (2002). Anti-Party Sentiments in Southern Europe.
In Gunther, R., Montero, J. R., & Linz, J. J. (Eds.), Political Parties: Old Concepts and New Challenges (pp. 257-290). Oxford University Press.
Tronconi, F. (2015). The Italian Party System and the Anti-Party Challenge. In De Petris, A., & Poguntke, T. (Eds.), Anti-Party Parties in Germany and Italy: Protest Movements and Parliamentary Democracy (pp. 213-256). Roma: Luiss University Press.
Turco, S. (2017). Dalle mazzette ai diamanti, tutti i guai della Lega Nord. L’Espresso: La Repubblica. Retrieved from: http://espresso.repubblica.it/attualita/2017/09/28/news/dalle-mazzette-ai-diamanti tutti-i-guai-della-lega-nord-1.311014
Viola, A. (2019a). Caso Diciotti, per salvare le poltrone i grillini sono pronti a evitare a Salvini un normale processo. Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2019/02/18/caso-diciotti-per-salvare-le-poltrone-i grillini-sono-pronti-a-evitare-a-salvini-un-normale-processo/4979682/
Viola, A. (2019b). Diciotti, così la diabolica strategia di Salvini ha smascherato i cinque stelle. Il Fatto Quotidiano. Retrieved from: https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2019/01/29/diciotti-cosi-la-diabolica-strategia-di salvini-ha-smascherato-i-cinque-stelle/4933062/
Vittori, D. (2017). Podemos and the Five Stars Movement: Divergent trajectories in a similar crisis. Constellations, 24(3), 324-338.
Ware, A. (2005). American exceptionalism. In Katz, R. S., & Crotty, W. (Eds.), Handbook of Party Politics (pp. 270-277). London: Sage Publications.
Webb, P. D. (1996). Apartisanship and anti-party sentiment in the United Kingdom: Correlates and constraints. European Journal of Political Research, 29(3), 365-382.
Weststeijn, A., & Corduwener, P. (2019). The roots and consequences of Italy’s political experiment. Cligendael Institute. Retrieved from: https://spectator.clingendael.org/en/publication/roots-and-consequences-italys political-experiment
Zulianello, M. (2017). Anti-System Parties Revisited: Concept Formation and Guidelines for Empirical Research, Government and Opposition, 53(4), 653-681.
